Scotland’s anti-free speech law has passed, making it one of the West’s most oppressive countries for speech

Scotland’s highly controversial Hate Crime and Public Order Bill has passed with 82 votes in favor, 32 against, and four abstained.

Didi Rankovic
Reclaim the Net
Fri, 12 Mar 2021 

Scotland flag/icon

The bill, that has been hotly contested by freedom of speech advocates, builds on the already existing legislation criminalizing what’s termed as “stirring up” hatred against people based on race. But this time, Scotland has made it a crime to “stir up hatred against protected groups.”

Reports say that few laws adopted by the Scottish Parliament in the 20 years of its existence have been more disputed. According to them, Justice Secretary Humza Yousaf from the ruling SNP, who tabled the bill, had to make several concessions and introduce changes to the original draft in order to try to reassure those who think freedom of speech is now in serious jeopardy in Scotland.

The bill’s broad and ambiguous definitions state that “intent” must be established to stir up hatred against protected groups, and it must pass “a reasonable person’s test before an offense has been committed.”

Background on the law:
– Rights groups push back against Scotland’s proposed hate speech law
– In Scotland, saying that sex is binary could soon be a crime
– Scotland’s hate speech law is vague and dangerous for free speech, expert says
– Free speech exception to Scottish hate crime bill withdrawn after backlash from SNP members
– Authors, comedians, and actors push back against Scotland’s authoritarian Hate Speech bill

Yousaf’s amendment said that criticizing or discussing “protected characteristics” would not in itself be considered a hate crime, as threats and abuse, while Justice Committee Convener Adam Tomkins, from opposition Conservatives, also contributed with an amendment that sought to incorporate the spirit of Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Right, so the new bill now allows Scots to “offend, shock or disturb” without being punished.

But another Conservative, Liam Kerr, described the bill as still fundamentally flawed despite the changes introduced in order to improve it, adding that there was no proper balance in the legation both protecting free speech and preventing hate, and said the party would not back it.

However, other opposition parties did, with Labour representative Neil Bibby saying his party has adopted a zero tolerance approach to hate crime and backs the government in using “the full force of the law” in dealing with it.

Both Kerr and Bibby criticized the final draft for not including sex as one of the “protected characteristics” considering that women often become targets of hate crime because of their sex.

One fear the bill’s critics expressed earlier was that people would not be allowed to utter “controversial” stances about certain groups even in their own homes, and could end up charged with committing a hate crime – but those who backed the bill now say that is not the case.

Little speech

Martin comments: Similar revisions to Freedom of speech laws coming to NZ soon. Watch how you say what you wish to say!

Uncensored is being censored
Get your copy from our Online Store or your local book and magazine retailer
Australian Retail Locations » Uncensored Publications Limited
New Zealand Retail Locations » Uncensored Publications Limited
As censorship heats up and free thought becomes an increasingly rare commodity, we appeal to our readers to support our efforts to reach people with information now being censored elsewhere. In the last few years, Uncensored has itself been censored, removed from the shelves of two of our biggest NZ retailers – Countdown Supermarkets and Whitcoulls Bookstores – accounting for 74% of our total NZ sales.
You can help keep the Free Press alive by subscribing and/or gifting a subscription to your friends and relatives.

Martin Harris

I have a lovely partner and 3 very active youngsters. We live in the earthquake ravaged Eastern Suburbs of Christchurch, New Zealand. I began commenting/posting on Uncensored back in early 2012 looking for discussion and answers on the cause and agendas relating to our quakes. I have always maintained an interest in ancient mysteries, UFOs, hidden agendas, geoengineering and secret societies and keep a close eye on current world events. Since 2013 I have been an active member of community, being granted admin status and publishing many blogs and discussion threads. At this time I'm now helping out with admin and moderation duties here at Uncensored where my online "life" began.

Next Post

The U.S. Military Connection to 5G and Why Americans Should Be Concerned About Deployment on Land and in Space

Wed Mar 17 , 2021
“Death from above” via Military 5G as The Night of a Thousand Stars becomes reality! MH By B.N. Frank Cities AND entire countries have taken action to ban, delay, halt, and limit 5G installation AS WELL AS issue moratoriums. The majority of scientists worldwide oppose deployment.  Recently, a 5G satellite moratorium was implemented in South Africa […]
5g boycott